Disney World has officially announced the closure of one of its most iconic attractions, Tom Sawyer Island, to make way for a new Cars-themed ride in the Magic Kingdom’s Frontierland. The news, shared during the August D23 Disney fan convention, came as part of a wider update from Disney Experiences chairman, Josh D’Amaro. This ambitious slate of new attractions also includes a villains-themed land in the Magic Kingdom and a Coco ride at California Adventure. However, the closure of Tom Sawyer Island has sparked mixed reactions from Disney fans.
Mixed Reactions from Disney Fans
While some Disney enthusiasts welcomed the news of the Cars attraction, many were outraged at the idea of losing Tom Sawyer Island, an attraction with a direct connection to Walt Disney himself. Some have expressed disappointment, arguing that the decision undermines the nostalgia and charm the island represents. One passionate fan even stated, “This will be the worst mistake Disney has ever made.” On the other hand, defenders of the move claim that Tom Sawyer Island was no longer a popular attraction and that its replacement with a Cars-themed ride would draw more visitors.
A Unique and Underappreciated Attraction
Tom Sawyer Island is one of the few attractions at Disney World that allows for a slower-paced experience. Rather than waiting in line for a ride, visitors could explore at their own pace. The island features rickety rope bridges, abandoned forts, and hidden caves, creating an adventurous playground for children and adults alike. Walt Disney himself was involved in the original design of the Disneyland version, inspired by his own childhood fantasies.
ALSO SEE: Refurbishment Begins at Disney’s Polynesian Village Resort Bungalows
The island provided a refreshing break from the hustle and bustle of the theme park, especially for families overwhelmed by the crowds. For many, it offered a much-needed respite, a place to sit in rocking chairs, sip drinks, and take in the peaceful surroundings. As Disney World becomes increasingly crowded, Tom Sawyer Island offered an oasis, away from the hectic rides and noisy crowds.
Why Its Loss Will Be Felt
Though the new Cars attraction will likely be a hit with families, some visitors feel the loss of Tom Sawyer Island will leave a noticeable gap in the park’s offerings. The island’s unique appeal—allowing children to play and explore rather than passively enjoy a ride—set it apart from other attractions. Many believe that, while the Cars ride may bring in more revenue, it will diminish the charm and balance of the park.
The removal of Tom Sawyer Island is set for early 2025, and while many visitors will enjoy the upcoming Cars feature, longtime fans will hold on to their memories of exploring the island’s secret corners.